Thursday, November 19, 2026

Lucy Miles’ Photogenic Mind, by Aaron Tillman

 


Lucy Miles’ Photogenic Mind, by Aaron Tillman


Regal House Publishing, 262 pages, $20.95


Reviewed by Off the Shelf Correspondent Kevin M. McIntosh



If you’re very, very lucky, you have one: a friend who sees to the heart of things, who tells you, like it or not, the necessary truths. Aaron Tillman, Associate Director of the Writing Program at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, has given us just such a person in the title character of his compelling “magical realist mystery novel” Lucy Miles’ Photogenic Mind.


This teenage Cassandra meets a fellow outsider, “fun-sized” high school sophomore, Pinchas “Pinky” Green, one evening on Calamity Beach, adolescent hangout spot of their Cape Cod hometown. She rescues the diminutive Pinky from his taunting peers and abusive older cousin Brandon, and he is mesmerized by his rescuer. Lucy liberates Pinky emotionally too, offering a tough-love vision of what his life could be. “There I was,” he confesses, “moved in all senses, drawn to the dark magnet of this white-faced girl with her long coffee-brown hair and hard black eyes.”


But those black eyes, he learns, are hard for a reason. Along with a knack for truth-telling, Lucy is gifted with a photogenic mind, the ability to see things others don’t, to store those images, manipulate them at will, and project them through those dark eyes when necessary. Her photographer father, discovering his daughter’s secret talent, downloads her images––more striking than his own––on his “Reader” and sells them as his work. Lucy’s chemist mother having disappeared, mysteriously, a decade earlier, Lucy is dragged from gig to gig, her father’s “camera” and meal ticket.


When her long-lost mother washes up, dead, on their neighborhood beach, and her father, too, is found deceased, Lucy is suddenly on the lam. Now we are in whodunit territory: Did Lucy’s dad kill his estranged wife? Did Lucy kill the father who held her captive to his photography career? Unto this breach comes an unlikely (and hilarious) trio: tiny Pinky; horsey, salty-tongued Gilda, owner of the beachside Cockaroost Concessions; and Walter, Lucy’s godfather, a Boston Police detective on suspension for attacking his soon-to-be ex-wife’s divorce-lawyer boyfriend. Can they find Lucy before the local cops––or the killers of Lucy’s parents––find her?


In this pursuit, Tillman subverts our expectations in most entertaining fashion. Like the trio who took on that Wicked Witch, each member of this triumvirate displays an unlikely strength: undersized Pinky proves tenacious as a terrier; Walter, the cop, displays an appealing emotional vulnerability; and Gilda, who has a deprecating nickname for everyone she meets, has a heart of gold. (Well, maybe we saw that one coming.) The vivid Cape Cod setting surprises too, with Pinky discovering his parents’ alternative . . . lifestyle choice, behavior one associates less with the Cape’s conservative bicep and more with its arty, free-thinking fingertip.


A novel that is simultaneously magical, realistic, and mysterious requires much of a reader, and this one found me wrestling with questions of genre. Was I captivated by literary speculative fiction? Engrossed in a surprisingly funny detective tale? Finally, I kicked back, let go, and enjoyed the wild ride. And paused to consider Lucy’s singular gift metaphorically. Three outsiders joining forces to seek justice for a fearless truth-teller may be––it finally struck me––the fittest parable for our times.

No comments:

Post a Comment