Mother, One More
Thing
Poems by Carla
Schwartz
Copyright 2014 by
Carla Schwartz
Turning Point
Books
Cincinnati, OH
45254
Softbound, 79 pages,
no price
ISBN 9781625490728
Review by Zvi A. Sesling
Carla Schwartz
like many a daughter thinks a lot about her departed mother. Unlike many
daughters, however, she writes poetry about the woman who birthed her. So, while this poetry book is about her
mother, it is ultimately about herself. Whenever one writes about someone, it
seems the choice of subject matter of each poem, the words and the descriptions
reveal more about the author than the subject – though the subject is also
bared in the process
November
The box descends
braced by planks
and strapped to
hands,
square, thin,
raw.
Pine, like all
others like it,
except for the
remains.
We commence the
burial
with shovels full
of sandy soil,
our final
send-off to what now is just a corpse
the body whose
womb I traversed,
who held me
through the worst turns.
I held her, those
last days
when, to rays streaming
through the room,
to Death itself
my mother –
joyous, rapt,
proposed the
seeming impossible task:
Let’s go outside!
There are also a
number of poems dealing with sex – some maybe are about her mother, some about
Ms. Schwartz, some are a bit more explicit than others, but whatever, her poems
keep the reader interested and moving through the book.
The final poem is
the title poem and reveals, perhaps, the most of Ms. Schwartz sensitive nature
as opposed to what might more carnal or more nostalgic writing:
Mother, One More
Thing
A Wellfleet house
with sloped ceilings and white walls,
pink light
through the trees early morning.
Three large
casements on two walls and skylight.
The ceiling
follows the slope of the roof.
The casement on
the north wall, raised.
Outside, inside
our bedroom.
Copies of famous
painting, sprinkled throughout
in subdued reds,
browns, blacks, and whites.
The furnishings,
simple, from the fifties,
with minor
updates each decade.
Mother, you don’t
know this, you haven’t been there.
One corner we
never explored. The painting belong
to the owners. In
good taste, but not yours.
Best of all, the
pond. It has your name.
I slip in every
morning for a swim.
Right after you
come to me in dream. After I stretch.
After the
subjugation resembling love.
What can be most
interesting about these poems is that they are often written to throw the
reader off – a word missing here or there, as in the last stanza above: “Right
after you come to me in dream.” Most
writers would write “in a dream.” But
the effect here to stop the reader if only for an instant, if only to make you
think and think again with what follows. There are also a plethora of commas to
slow you down or to make you think they are not all necessary. A hidden
trick? Is it conscious and
thoughtful? There are a number of
enigmas in her writing and it is up to the reader to decide on it.
And finally,
there is a lot of soul bearing, which many poets seem to do, some not as
effectively as Ms. Schwartz.
__________________________________________________
Zvi A. Sesling
Reviewer, Boston Area Small Press and Poetry Scene
Author, King of the Jungle and Across Stones of Bad Dreams
Publisher, Muddy River Books
Editor, Muddy River Poetry Review
Editor, Bagel Bards Anthology
Zvi Sesling’s review of Carla Schwartz's book, Mother One More Thing, tells more about the reviewer, than about that book. Mr. Sesling did not let this tenderly voluptuous book get under his skin as is the obligation of any good reviewer. It appears, instead, that he gave it a perfunctory read and scribbled down a few perfunctory notes, which he then fleshed out just as quickly. He might have simply said "Carla Schwartz writes like a girl. I like the book," and left it at that.
ReplyDeleteMr. Sesling makes the inept and unprofessional mistake of identifying the speaker in each poem as the poet herself. In so doing, he reduces her boldly sensual language to confession. His references to sex and carnality border on misogyny, and overshadow his assessment of the sensitivity of her writing. His occasional positive comments are broad-brushed and generic.
Mr. Sesling ends with a few copy edits concerning her use of commons and words intentionally omitted. I hope, if he continues to write reviews, that he is more respectful and attentive of the books he is critiquing. This review dismisses the intimacy and red-bloodedness that so many good poets risk, among them Carla Schwartz, who not only takes that risk, but stands tall in taking it.