Among the Enigmas Poems by Robert Murphy

Among the Enigmas

Poems by Robert Murphy

Artwork by Donald Golder

Dos Madres Press

www.dosmadres.com

ISBN: 978-1-948017-52-7

61 Pages

Review by Dennis Daly

Without an inductive or deductive leg to stand on, Robert Murphy, in his new collection of poetry, Among the Enigmas, nails the existential perplexities that niggle our attempts to apprehend human consciousness and metaphysical selfhood. Quite an accomplishment! He achieves his ends with humor, wordplay, and puckish subversions, marbled throughout with his singular warmth and kindliness.

Additionally, most of Murphy’s poems are paired up with intriguing artwork by Donald Golder. Golder’s ink drawings and watercolor images both complement the knotty verse puzzlements and tease away any trite conclusions.

Murphy opens his collection with a nod to poet William Bronk in a lovely piece entitled The Lay Of The Land—Hudson Falls New York, Just This Side Of Elysium. He recalls sending his fellow poet a myth laden daffodil, properly named poeticus narcissus. The flower was spoken of by Virgil and is associated with Persephone (she had been gathering them before her abduction into the Underworld) and Narcissus (the goddess Nemesis turned him into the flower). Bronk, who lived Hudson Falls New York, died there in 1999. Here is the heart of Murphy’s poem,

I sent Bill the poet’s flower, poeticus narcissus, variety

old pheasant eye. Those ones that are fragrant,

almost impossibly so, an echo of the Mediterranean world

from which they come, pure white, with six (as it is described

in the catalogs) perianth segments on a single stem,

petals slightly recurved; with a small, red rimmed

ruffled yellow cup into which you might pour yourself

to lie within reflected—the last of its kind to bloom,

                                                      late spring.

Turning the Cartesian philosophical proposition Cogito, ergo sum on its head, Jean Paul Sartre famously declared I am, therefore I think. Yet Sartre did not believe that the “I” even exists. In fact he declared it a fiction. Murphy seems to buy into Sartre with one exception: he concocts his “I” as a dynamic, but empty, container of sorts, enabling what was already there. Two of the poet’s early pieces make this clear. In The Real Problem Is, Murphy characterizes internal consciousness as an alien invader. The poet explains,

…we live,

Colonized, inhabited by

Thoughts as much unlived as we

Whose words survive us—

Life having fled with the naming of things

Murphy effects much the same proposition from a different angle in his poem The Times. In the process he reroutes Heraclitus’ famous river into a circular flow. Murphy illuminates the action,

… every day is

Brought back to life in us to live

Where what was, otherwise,

Would never think to do, does,

And remembered so

Time and Again

Has its way with us.

The poet warns his readers against the use of rational tools in delving into life’s appearances.  Murphy winks while comically employing cliché after cliché in making his case. He plays the Holy Fool with sacerdotal expertise. Speaking of these same appearances he says,

Hidden in plain sight as they always are

Right under our noses…

(if not the coffee, try the roses)

And just out of earshot too, 

     -- “Listen up!” –

Fact is, if facts mattered,

And they don’t.

Not in any real world:

Priest, Rabbi, Mullah,

Good Time Evangelical Rock and Roller.

Dear Mother of God, it’s true.

And you’re dead right.

When not for the first time

You find a serpent

In your shoe…

Jumping Jehoshaphat!”

My friend, have faith.

In Murphy’s poem entitled At the Border he ruminates on the very meaning of “I.” Observing the phenomenon of consciousness at work is not enough. His name is attached and that means something. Or does it? The poet considers his connundrum,

Trying to convince the authorities

We are who we say we are:

Those who know us best.

Ourselves being the ones we are

Most desperate to convince.

For a lot of us being human means making the best of things. Shadows menace us on the outskirts of our world. Yet, somehow, we must pass the time, we must continue as our nature demands. Something on life’s extremity, just out of sight awaits us with answers. We are pretty sure of it. Murphy, in his piece Shelter in Place, spells it out this way,

…still we are waiting

To be told what it is at the edge of our lives

That shadows us—

What it is that keeps us so at bay.

“Shelter in place!” “Shelter in place!”

Neither knowing how it came to be,

Nor how it must surely end.

We do what we can to pass the time of day.

Some tell stories, others joke,

The more guarded listen and look.

Of the unaccountable, no one will say.

Perhaps the most compelling poems in Murphy’s collection he saves for last. His Imp sequence of nine poems wrestles with the duality concept of mind and body, conjuring up the absurd construction of self. In Imp, the first piece in the series, Murphy opens by setting the conversational tone of gleeful wordplay,

Lord knows, for who should know better than I,

bottled up as you and I have been, the two of us, together.

What is it now, near to a lifetime? Ah, the soul,

the soul! How in the end we worry about its disposition,

as if the body, too, wasn’t just another name

for what you would, if you could, sell

separately on the cheap, down river. Admit it, though,

if wishes were fishes,… didn’t I reel you in a boat load?

Yeah, and beware of what you wish for. I hear you.

Yes, Murphy’s readers hear him too—both his oracular wit and his musical inquiry. And, in my experience, once one hearkens to Murphy’s especial brand of poetry, one wants, nay, one needs more.